The cleanest way to print an MTGGoldfish decklist as proxies is to export the list as text, separate the playable deck from optional cards, verify quantities, and then review every matched card before approving the project. Do not treat the export as a finished order. It identifies the cards you want, but it may not preserve the exact art, set, frame, tokens, or double-sided components you expect.
This workflow works for both 60-card decks and Commander lists. The important difference is the preflight count: a competitive Constructed project may include a main deck and separate sideboard, while a Commander project normally needs one commander plus 99 other cards before tokens and helper cards are added.
Export the MTGGoldfish decklist as text
Open the deck page in MTGGoldfish, select Download, and choose Text File (Default). That produces a quantity-and-card-name list that can be copied into an editable document or compatible card-list importer. MTGGoldfish also offers an Arena export, but the plain-text download is usually easier to inspect and clean for a physical print project.
Keep an untouched copy of that original export. Create a second working copy for cleanup. If an importer cannot retrieve the MTGGoldfish URL directly, pasting exported text avoids making the project depend on direct page access.
A useful working list puts one quantity and one card name on each line:
- 4 Lightning Bolt
- 2 Spell Pierce
- 10 Island
Combine repeated copies of the same card into one line. A single “10 Island” entry is much easier to audit than ten separate basic-land lines.
Separate the main deck, sideboard, and optional cards
Do not paste every section into the importer as one undifferentiated block. Create separate sections or files for the main deck, sideboard, tokens, and optional cards. Remove headings, notes, prices, category labels, and maybeboard entries unless the receiving importer explicitly understands them.
For a 60-card Constructed deck
Count the main deck and sideboard independently. Under the current Magic Tournament Rules, a Constructed main deck contains at least 60 cards, and a sideboard may contain no more than 15. The usual four-copy limit applies across the combined main deck and sideboard, apart from basic lands and cards whose text permits another quantity.
Those rules give you a useful audit even when the printed deck is only for testing. A 60-card main deck plus a 15-card sideboard should become 75 playable cards, not 60 cards with the sideboard accidentally omitted or 90 cards because the full list was pasted twice. Keep tokens and substitute cards outside the sideboard stack.
For a Commander deck
Check that the commander appears exactly once and that the playable deck totals 100 cards including that commander. Official Commander format guidance defines the deck as 99 cards plus one commander, with singleton construction apart from basic lands. Included cards must also fit the commander’s color identity.
Pay special attention to basic lands. A text export containing 12 Forest and 10 Island is fine if those quantities are intentional. Nonbasic duplicates deserve another look: they may be an import mistake, or they may be different cards with similar names. Maybeboard cards do not belong in the 100-card count unless you deliberately move them into the deck.
Clean the list before importing it
Run through the working copy line by line. The goal is a list that another person could count without opening the MTGGoldfish page.
- Remove section labels or annotations the destination does not support.
- Correct misspellings and preserve punctuation in official card names.
- Confirm that split cards and Adventures use names the importer recognizes.
- Delete maybeboard entries unless you intend to print them as extras.
- Decide whether basic lands belong in the batch or will come from an existing collection.
- Check that the deck was not pasted or imported twice.
- Record the main-deck, sideboard, and extras subtotals before continuing.
If a card fails to match, search for that card individually rather than repeatedly submitting the entire deck. Reimporting without checking the existing card count is an easy way to create duplicate copies.
Choose card versions instead of accepting every default
A basic MTGGoldfish text export usually gives you quantities and card names, not a guaranteed printing, frame, or artwork. The next tool may therefore select a valid version that is different from the one shown on the deck page.
Edition data also needs careful handling. MTGGoldfish’s import-format documentation says its import formats use Magic Online set codes, which can differ from codes used by other sites. Verify any edition identifiers rather than assuming every platform interprets them identically.
Review versions individually when the choice matters, especially for borderless treatments, retro frames, showcase cards, text-heavy older printings, basic-land art, and cards with several mechanically equivalent presentations. When supported, a set code and collector number provide a more precise identifier than a card name alone. Even then, inspect the resulting match before approval.
Account for double-sided cards, tokens, and helpers
An exported decklist is a construction list, not a complete inventory of every physical component needed during play. Check MDFCs, transform cards, meld pairs, Battles, split cards, and Adventures separately. For double-sided cards, verify that the correct front and back are paired in the proof; the name-only import may not make that relationship obvious. The full pairing process is covered in the guide to printing transform cards as double-sided proxies.
Tokens also require their own pass. A deck can create several token types without listing any of them in its 60 or 100 playable cards. Add the quantities you actually expect to use, along with emblems, helper cards, copy tokens, or day/night reminders. Commander projects can use the Commander token checklist to build that extras batch.
Import and proof the physical project
Once the list is clean, paste only the intended order lines into the destination. For a paste-and-review workflow, PrintMTG card printing for MTG proxies and physical playtest cards provides a relevant next step. Review the matched card count immediately after import, before spending time changing individual versions.
- Main deck subtotal matches the cleaned list.
- Sideboard is included once and remains identifiable.
- Commander is present once and the playable deck totals 100 cards.
- Basics have intentional quantities and artwork choices.
- Selected sets, frames, and collector numbers are correct where they matter.
- MDFCs and transform cards have the intended paired faces.
- Tokens and helper cards are counted as extras, not as deck cards.
- No maybeboard cards or duplicate imports slipped into the batch.
Keep proxy and playtest cards clearly distinct from authentic cards. Wizards states that sanctioned events require authentic Magic cards and uses “proxy” in tournament policy for limited judge- or organizer-issued replacements. Unofficial playtest cards belong in casual play and testing rather than sanctioned competition. Wizards’ proxy policy explanation provides the relevant distinction.
Archive the exact version you approved
Save the original MTGGoldfish export, the cleaned list, section subtotals, selected set and collector identifiers, and the final proof. Give the folder a deck name and date. If you revise the deck later, create a new version instead of overwriting the approved one.
Before submitting the project, perform one final count from the proof rather than from the MTGGoldfish page: main deck plus sideboard or commander package, then tokens and helpers as a separate subtotal. That last comparison is what turns a convenient deck export into a repeatable physical print project.